17 Comments
User's avatar
David Carroll's avatar

As usual, full of Schiff. You never mention the massacre, never mention that the Palestinians overwhelmingly support Hamas and fundamental Islamism. So intersectional. So biased. So wrong. On this story Tom, you miss the picture.

Thomas Fazi's avatar

That's a lot of words just to say that you support genocide.

David Carroll's avatar

I support the right of Israel to defend itself. They did not start this. You seem not to have noticed. So groovy ;)

Thomas Fazi's avatar

Defenders of genocide will always find ways to rationalise what they're supporting.

David Carroll's avatar

You did not answer my question. In your analysis, the massacre did not happen, Hamas was and is not present, the Palestinians have no culpability and fundamental Islamism played no role. Is the act of Israel defending itself and fighting to get its hostages back an act of genocide? Pray tell.

amba's avatar

To say that Israel is “defending itself” against thousands of children sounds deranged.

David Carroll's avatar

Do you believe everything the MS BDS media regurgitates from Hamas? Do you believe Israel is really an apartheid state? Were you educated at Harvard ;). If so maybe you go fight with the Palestinians and Hamas. I wonder what they might do to an apostate who shows up thinking this is an intersectional conflict between the oppressor and the oppressed.

Kostas K's avatar

Really sorry but the case against Israel is not about its right of self defense but how it is exercising it. Self defense DOES NOT allow for genocide or collective punishment.

By the way, you really MUST read your history. ICJ has already decided in a 2003 case (about Israel constructing its "border wall") that Israel is an occupying force and DOES NOT have a right to self defense.

David Carroll's avatar

“The case against” . This is not a case, it is war. Started by violent, fundamentalists. They took hostages and massacred families. They have vowed to destroy the people of Israel. All of them. They came from and were supported by the Palestinians. Still are.

Kostas K's avatar

"This is not a case, it is war."

Grow up. War HAS rules and there are international treaties concerning war. As well as International Courts of Justice. The reason Israel ITSELF has signed the treaty creating ICJ is exactly the fact that a war cannot be used as a pretext for mass killing, genocide and collective punishment. As evident in the historical event that was the reason for creating the state of Israel.

You are writing arguments with an intellectual coherence of a 14 year old.

David Carroll's avatar

It is war and you my friend believe everything the Islamists tell you. You have been indoctrinated to think this way. Think about it, when did you first call for ceasefire? Genocide? The Violent antisemite left was waiting for this moment. They almost knocked down the fence to the White House last night. Oh. Peaceful protest ;). They CAIR

David Carroll's avatar

Delusional, inculcated, and intersectionality naive.

Rosanna Leman's avatar

No he doesn't, You really need to give it some critical thought. You do bad things you get bad things

Guess u wouldn't mind if u have a bulldozer pull down your home and then get told to bugger off eh.